Essay · 12 October 2026
The cash flow method
A rental property is a small machine that takes rent in and pushes costs, interest and tax out. We analyse it as that machine. We do not analyse it as a hope that the building will be worth more later.
What we count, in order
Start with the rent a willing tenant would actually pay for twelve months, not the headline the listing wants. Call that gross rent. Then take off a vacant allowance. What remains is effective rent: the cash you can plausibly collect.
From effective rent, subtract operating costs you will pay whether or not the mortgage exists. Insurance. A repairs reserve. Gas safety, electrical inspection, and any licence the local authority requires. Management, if you will not do the 11pm phone call yourself. Service charge and ground rent, if the title is leasehold. Council tax and utilities for the weeks the property is empty, if they are not already inside the void allowance. The remainder is net operating income. In the trade it is often shortened to NOI. It is the property’s cash before the lender and before HMRC.
Only then subtract debt service. On an interest-only loan that is the interest. On a repayment loan it is interest plus the capital the lender takes back each month. Both are cash leaving the account. Only the interest is a finance cost for tax, and even that statement needs the next paragraph.
Tax comes last, because it depends on who owns the property. An individual basic-rate taxpayer, an individual higher-rate taxpayer, and a company do not keep the same residue from the same NOI. Section 24 of the Income Tax (Trading and Other Income) Act 2005 restricts relief on finance costs for individual residential landlords: interest is not deducted in full from rental profit. A basic-rate tax reduction, currently described as twenty per cent of the finance cost, is given instead. A company that is carrying on a property business can still deduct interest as an expense, and then pays corporation tax on what remains. Getting the money out of the company is a second tax event. None of this is a recommendation to incorporate. It is a reason to put the owner on the page before celebrating the yield.
What we refuse to count as income
We do not add “expected capital growth” to the year’s cash. A higher valuation does not pay the boiler invoice. It may increase equity, and equity is real, but it is not cash until a buyer, a refinance that the lender will actually offer, or a sale completes. We mention equity in a separate sentence so it cannot quietly rescue a negative cash year.
We also do not treat the tenant’s deposit as income. It is someone else’s money, held on rules that are not optional. Spending it because the current account looks thin is how small portfolios get into arguments they then lose.
An annotated stack
Illustration only. A freehold two-bedroom terrace bought in England for £145,000, let at £800 a month. Interest-only loan at 75 per cent of price, interest 5.25 per cent. One month vacant. Management at 10 per cent plus VAT on rent actually collected. These are round teaching numbers, not a valuation of any street in Alnwick or anywhere else.
| Line | How we got it | Pounds |
|---|---|---|
| Gross rent | £800 × 12 | 9,600 |
| Vacant allowance | One month | −800 |
| Effective rent | Collected | 8,800 |
| Management | 12% of £8,800 | −1,056 |
| Insurance | Buildings, round figure | −260 |
| Repairs reserve | Not a quote | −600 |
| Compliance | Certificates, averaged | −200 |
| NOI | Effective rent less operating costs | 6,684 |
| Interest | 5.25% of a £108,750 loan | −5,709 |
| Cash before tax | NOI less interest | 975 |
Nine hundred and seventy-five pounds before tax, on cash put in of roughly £45,700 once a 25 per cent deposit, English additional-dwelling SDLT and a modest fees allowance are counted. That is a cash-on-cash figure near 2 per cent, before the owner’s tax. The worked examples show why a higher-rate individual can watch that residue disappear, and why a company keeps a different residue that is still not the same thing as money in a personal current account.
Purchase cash is part of the return
Cash-on-cash uses every pound you cannot spend elsewhere: deposit, SDLT, legal fees, survey, broker fee if there is one, and any works required before the first tenancy. Leaving SDLT out of the denominator is how a thin deal is made to look tidy. On this illustration, English additional-dwelling SDLT on £145,000 is £6,250 on the first £125,000 at 5 per cent and £1,400 on the remaining £20,000 at 7 per cent, so £7,650. That figure is the 2026/27 English higher-rates schedule as we read it. It is not the Scottish or Welsh bill.
Stress the year you would not post
Re-run the stack with the interest rate two percentage points higher, and again with eight vacant weeks instead of four. If either version cannot pay the lender and the insurer without new savings, the base case was a wish. The yield and gearing essay has a calculator for that second pass. It still ignores tax, on purpose, so you can see the property before the owner.